The letter A seemed like the most obvious place to start. I did a google image search and came across lots of A crafts, but my favorite by far was the craft that turned the capital letter A into an alligator. I found a full page print out of the Letter A cut it out and used it as a stencil to to cut out green letter A's, then cut small white and green triangles for eyes and teeth. I also handed out crayons so that each of the kids could draw eyes into the green triangles and write their name on their alligator.
I read 4 books and did 2 songs. For this story time I picked three alphabet books and one story book that focused on something that began with the letter A. I also do the alphabet song and the hokey pokey because it helps get the wiggles out.
For the letter A story time I read: Max's ABC by Rosemary Wells
Alligator Alphabet by Stella Blackstone
Chicka Chicka Boom Boom by Martin Bill Jr.
Apple Farmer Annie by Monica Wellington
The Max and Ruby book was by far the most popular of the four books, and Chicka Chicka Boom Boom would have been more successful if I had gotten more of the kids to say the words along with me. The other books were fairly well received. All in all it was a good story time for my first time handling the whole thing.